Doppelgänger modules, or The Curse of EightPlusThree (7.1.2006)

Windows, even in its latest incarnations, still exhibits quite a bit of quirky behavior which is due to its DOS roots, or at least due to the attempt to remain compatible with code which was created for DOS. Most of the time, I am not even surprised anymore when I come across 16-bit limitations or similar reminiscences of the past. But sometimes, I only become aware of them when my code crashes.

This happened some time ago with an application I am working on. When I started the app in a certain way, it would simply crash very early during startup. It took a while to break this down into the following trivial code example which consists of a main executable and a DLL which is loaded into the executable via LoadLibrary, i.e. dynamically. Here is the code for the main executable, SampleApp.cpp:

#include <stdio.h>
#include <conio.h>
#include <windows.h>
#include <psapi.h>

static void EnumModules(const char *msg)
{
  printf("\n==========================================================\n");
  printf("List of modules in the current process %s:\n", msg);

  HMODULE hMods[1024];
  DWORD cbNeeded;
  HANDLE hProcess = GetCurrentProcess();

  // inquire modules loaded into process
  if( EnumProcessModules(hProcess, hMods, sizeof(hMods), &cbNeeded)) {
    // print name and handle for each module
    for ( unsigned int i = 0; i < (cbNeeded/sizeof(HMODULE)); i++ ) {
      char szModName[MAX_PATH];
      if ( GetModuleFileNameEx( hProcess, hMods[i], szModName, sizeof(szModName))) {
        printf("  %s (0x%08X)\n", szModName, hMods[i] );
      }
    }
  }

  CloseHandle( hProcess );
}

extern "C" __declspec(dllexport) int functionInExe(void)
{
  printf("Now in functionInExe()\n");
  return 42;
}

int main(void)
{
  EnumModules("before loading DLL");
  HMODULE hmod = LoadLibrary("SampleDLL.dll");
  EnumModules("after loading DLL");

  printf("\nPress key to exit.\n");
  _getch();
  return 0;
}

This code loads a DLL called SampleDLL.dll. Before and after loading the DLL, it enumerates the modules which are currently loaded into the process; this is only to demonstrate the effect which led to the crash in the other app I was working on.

SampleDLL.dll is built from this code (SampleDLL.cpp):

extern "C" __declspec(dllimport) int functionInExe(void);

extern "C" __declspec(dllexport) void gazonk(void)
{
  int i = functionInExe();
}

The main executable exports a function called functionInExe, and the DLL calls this function, and so it has an explicit reference to the main executable which the linker needs to resolve. This is an important piece of the puzzle.

And here is a simple makefile which shows how to build the two modules:

all: SampleApplication.exe SampleDLL.dll

clean:
   del *.obj *.exe *.dll

SampleApplication.exe: SampleApp.obj
   link /debug /out:SampleApplication.exe SampleApp.obj psapi.lib

SampleApp.obj: SampleApp.cpp
   cl /Zi /c SampleApp.cpp

SampleDLL.dll: SampleDLL.obj
   link /debug /dll /out:SampleDLL.dll SampleDLL.obj SampleApplication.lib

SampleDLL.obj: SampleDLL.cpp
   cl /Zi /c SampleDLL.cpp

Let's assume that the above files (SampleApp.cpp, SampleDLL.cpp and makefile) are all in a directory c:\temp\dupemod, and that we built the code by running nmake in that directory. Now let's run the code as shown in the screenshots below.

Long filename Short filename


Take a close look at the command shell window on the right: After loading the DLL, the process maps both c:\temp\dupemod\Sample~1.exe and c:\temp\dupemod\SampleApplication.exe into its address space. Both refer, of course, to the same file, which means that we have loaded the executable twice!

This happens only if we run the executable using its 8+3 DOS name, i.e. Sample~1.exe. When run with a long filename, everything works as expected. So when we load SampleDLL.dll, the OS loader tries to resolve the references which this DLL makes to other modules. One of those modules is SampleApplication.exe. The OS loader should be able to map this reference to the instance of the executable which is already mapped into the address space. However, it seems that the OS loader cannot figure out that Sample~1.exe and SampleApplication.exe are actually the same file, and therefore loads another instance of the executable!

BTW, this happens both on Windows 2000 and Windows XP systems. In this trivial example, the only damage done is probably just that the main executable consumes twice the virtual address space. In a large application, the consequences can be more severe, and in our case they were. Microsoft also documents some effects of this issue in Knowledge Base articles, for example KB218475 and KB193513.

The only workarounds I see are:

  • Rename the executable to that it uses a name which fits into the 8+3 format.
  • Make sure that nobody ever runs the executable using its short name.

We basically went with the latter approach - by making sure that end users always run the application by double-clicking shortcuts which contain the full executable name, and by fixing an interesting related bug in ATL which, hopefully, I may have the time and the nerves to describe in more detail one fine day...


When asked for a TWiki account, use your own or the default TWikiGuest account.



to top


You are here: Blog > BlogOnSoftware20060107

r1.1 - 17 Feb 2006 - 21:11 - ClausBrod to top

Blog
This site
RSS

  2017: 12 - 11 - 10
  2016: 10 - 7 - 3
  2015: 11 - 10 - 9 - 4 - 1
  2014: 5
  2013: 9 - 8 - 7 - 6 - 5
  2012: 2 - 10
  2011: 1 - 8 - 9 - 10 - 12
  2010: 11 - 10 - 9 - 4
  2009: 11 - 9 - 8 - 7 -
     6 - 5 - 4 - 3
  2008: 5 - 4 - 3 - 1
  2007: 12 - 8 - 7 - 6 -
     5 - 4 - 3 - 1
  2006: 4 - 3 - 2 - 1
  2005: 12 - 6 - 5 - 4
  2004: 12 - 11 - 10
  C++
  CoCreate Modeling
  COM & .NET
  Java
  Mac
  Lisp
  OpenSource
  Scripting
  Windows
  Stuff
Changes
Index
Search
Maintenance
Impressum
Datenschutzerklärung
Home



Jump:

Copyright © 1999-2024 by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? Send feedback